
Photo of newspaper stack via Daniel R. Blume on Wikimedia Commons; screenshot of text from the 1968 Kerner Commission report. Edits by James Salanga.
I got my first staff job in journalism, a paid Hearst Magazines internship, in 2005. Every few years since then, I’ve read the same assessment of diversity, equity, and inclusion in the field: “Racial and ethnic minorities … remain grossly underrepresented in the media industry.”
That particular statement is from a May 2026 Columbia Journalism Review article, which cites a 2023 Pew Research Center survey that 76% of “reporting journalists” identified as white. If a post-Trump minority-rule government continues, there’s little reason to assume that ratio will come to better reflect the racial/ethnic profile of modern U.S. towns, cities, and states.
I don’t mean to suggest that significant change hasn’t occurred since 2005. Over my career, I’ve seen the discourse broaden beyond race/ethnicity and cisgender female representation to also elevate transgender, viewpoint, class, and rural-urban diversity. That is progress.
What hasn’t sufficiently changed in response to our era, in my view, is the default approach to increasing diversity. Advocacy remains oriented, perhaps because of a mandate sourced from the 1968 Kerner Commission report, toward diversifying mainstream white newsrooms. But most, in 2026, are shadows of their former selves and politically-embattled. Irrelevance, not distrust, better describes their relationship with various U.S. publics.
So I’m curious about a different set of questions that move away from the Kerner approach to DEI. What field, exactly, are advocates asking that journalists of color and other minoritized identities be included in? How does inclusion better inform and connect our overlapping communities? At what point does it make sense to stop advocating to diversify a burning house?
FROM THE OBJECTIVE
Who exactly is telling this story? →
Who does journalism end up reaching?
Much of the conversation about DEI in journalism centers jobs and training for mainstream newsrooms, or, hearkening back to Kerner’s language, integrating white newsrooms.
In one sense, it’s understandable. Mainstream newsrooms and funders bankroll diversity programming like, the revamped Metpro Program, Chips Quinn, the Poynter Leadership Academy for Women, annual affinity association job fairs, and more.
But diversity advocates driven by the Kerner frame often overlook the smaller non-traditional, ethnic media, and hyperlocal outlets that produce news for, not about, the place-based communities that inspired many of us to become journalists in the first place.
“A less talked-about and overlooked part of the diversity conversation,” multimedia reporter Taylor Jung, 30, told me via Zoom, “is whether the communities that we serve are actually getting the news that we’re putting out.”

Taylor Jung selling her personal photojournalism work. Courtesy of Jung.
That Kerner approach also hasn’t arrested the public distrust of or disconnection from journalism that, irrespective of adding a non-white journalist to a mainstream newsroom, continues unabated.
News distribution and framing have long short-circuited journalism’s democracy-feedback loop, spiking both public distrust and disconnection. “Distrust” in news media around stereotypes and “journalistic objectivity” has been well-documented.
People across all ages, globally, are also less interested in news. The 2026 Reuters Institute Digital News Report found casual or passive news users increased to 25% from 16% in 2021. In the U.S., a 2025 Pew-Knight Initiative report finds that, since 2016, young adults consistently report the lowest news engagement. In a viral essay, journalist Olivia Hicks noted that many in her generation may not know what a journalist is, highlighting a third concern: media literacy.
Jung’s grasp of both day-to-day and field-level concerns is why she’s the young reporter in my network that I wanted to talk to. We met in 2024 after she agreed to be interviewed by my Rutgers-Newark journalism class. Soon after, I learned Jung had joined the unenviable throng of journalists being laid off from local newsrooms.
When we spoke, she highlighted a fatal civic weakness in our diversity discourse: “We put out stories [about our communities], but are they actually reaching them?”
Jung was freelancing until July, when I was thrilled to learn she landed a job where both community reach and newsroom diversity are moot. After weathering the brutal market with other colleagues in support networks like the Journalists of Color Slack and her Poynter Diverse Voices cohort, Jung is now senior editor of S. Mitra Kalita’s six-year-old start-up, Epicenter NYC, based in Jackson Heights, Queens.
It’s among a handful of new-generation newsrooms, zines, and content creators — including City Bureau’s Documenters, Documented, or El Tímpano — producing news by and for their respective community, and not just about it.
Epicenter, Jung says, is one of “so many bright spots that are making me hopeful for the direction of the industry.”
Evolving the Kerner approach to newsroom DEI
O.G. newsroom diversity researcher Gwyneth Mellinger, Ph.D., is a journalism historian and recently retired professor from James Madison University in Virginia. Her 2013 book, Chasing Newsroom Diversity, about the American Society of Newspaper Editors (ASNE), is a foundational text about newsroom integration and ASNE’s failed goal to ensure newsroom demographics matched those of the U.S. population. It helped me to age the structural inequalities that, at the time, were unraveling my own youthful ideal to help diversify newsrooms.
I noted that, among Mellinger’s findings, an earlier generation of journalists of color viewed newsrooms as confining and negative. Many left.
Given that the tide was already against diversity back then, Mellinger said, now, “I don’t look to formal DEI programs being able to help us anytime soon.”
That earlier generation of journalists is echoed in my Leavers survey, which published during the 2020 newsroom reckonings. A main finding confirmed anecdotal data that the industry was “leaking” trained JOCs — black women, mainly — at their mid-career mark.
So of course I asked Annemarie Dooling, program manager of News Creator Corps, to repeat herself when she said, “Most of our applicants are black women.”
“A diversity candidate for us,” Dooling said, “would be a white woman from a major city.”

Headshot of Annemarie Dooling. Courtesy of Dooling.
Launched in 2025, News Creator Corps provides support and journalism training to independent content creators who are already trusted by their niche communities. Most have full-time jobs in other fields and, unlike Project C, a network of independent journalists, are not pivoting away from newsrooms into independent journalism.
“Now, I’m not sure that ‘the newsroom’ is understood the same way by young people — and I don’t know if that is a bad thing,” Mellinger said.
In an age of distributed work and disruption, her questions about diversity are different than they were decades ago.
“How do you do newsroom diversity when ‘the newsroom’ is no longer a space that can be clearly defined?” she asks. “How do you count people who are everywhere and people who are not necessarily your employees?”
Perhaps the energies of diversity advocacy will follow the U.S. public, growing networks of content creators, and Leavers and swing away from traditional, mainstream newsrooms.
Wherever those energies concentrate, Meredith Clark, associate professor of race and political communication at University of North Carolina Hussman School of Journalism and Media, insists on the need to collect diversity data.
“The distributed nature of journalism organizations is one of the factors that destabilized the ability of [ASNE-turned-News Leaders Association] to collect that sort of data,” Clark said, referencing the disappointing end in 2022 to the industry’s newsroom diversity survey, which ASNE ran annually since 1978.
“To relinquish the attempt to collect that data is to say that the people who are holding those positions and their work doesn’t matter, in a certain sense,” she added.
“The disappearance of data is how you get to manipulate institutions and structures and policies and ultimately, people,” and is “the very reason that the current federal regime is doing all it can to dismantle data collection.”
I agree with Clark. And I’m pulled to a complementary approach: the future system that’s already showing. Like Epicenter NYC, in the News Creator incubator, race and gender diversity is already the default — leaving Dooling, a journalist without a college degree, to focus on metrics that also matter to creators’ niche audiences, like “your experiences and what you bring to the [cohort] from your background or your [work] life.”
Said differently: There may be something worth exploring in regenerating 21st century journalism from spaces where race and gender diversity is moot.
Carla Murphy is a thought leader in journalism and journalism education and a civic media organizer with News Futures. Find her work at About the American Mainstream on Substack.
This piece was edited by James Salanga. Copy edits by Marlee Baldridge.